But despite its initial appeal, the wager seems to fail on logical grounds. Very few of the wagers defenders, in fact, have retained more than an academic interest in its power to persuade. Tobin shows the bible, with its numerous contradictions, historical errors and scientific inaccuracies, cannot be considered inerrant. You can modify pascals wager to suggest a course of action for people coming from a different understanding of religion e. Drange the argument call it pw may be formulated as follows. As many scholars have pointed out, pascal was not so naive as to suppose that one could believe in god by an act of willhowever, he did think that belief could be developed by acting in certain religious. Pascals wager is finding ever more defenders who aim to undermine the old many gods objection. In his major work summa theologica, widely considered as the highest achievement of medieval systematic theology, aquinas presented his five proofs of gods existence known as the quinque viae latin for five ways. Mar 24, 2017 in this wireless philosophy video, susanna rinard harvard university explains pascal s wager, blaise pascal s famous argument for belief in god. Blaise pascal was a 17th century french philosopher, theologian, and. Faith healing perhaps one of the worst outcomes of the fundamentalist resurgence is the irrational belief in the power of prayer to perform faith healing. Paul tobin is the eisneraward winning, new york timesbestselling author of bandette, colder, and many other comic books and graphic series.
In his major work summa theologica, widely considered as the highest achievement of medieval systematic theology, aquinas presented his five proofs of god s existence known as the quinque viae latin for five ways. Pascal s wager is the most prominent theistic pragmatic argument, and issues in epistemology, the ethics of belief, and decision theory, as well as philosophical theology, all intersect at the wager. In this wireless philosophy video, susanna rinard harvard university explains pascals wager, blaise pascals famous argument for belief in god. To understand pascal s wager you have to understand the background of the argument. He was a child prodigy who was educated by his father, a tax collector in. The dilemma that republican policy makers confronted regarding exchanges was, as an insurance department official in a conservative state told us, reminiscent of pascal s wager.
Taking pascals wager by michael rota overdrive rakuten. The project gutenberg ebook of pascals pensees, by blaise. Examining two objections to pascals wager pascals wager has been the subject of protracted philosophical interest since its posthumous appearance over three centuries ago. In this form pascal s wager is a problem in decision making under uncertainty, a decision in which the outcome is uncertain and the probabilities of the outcome are unknown. If the christian god does exist, the agnostic gains. Oct 06, 2019 the book the rejection of pascal s wager.
Is it safer to believe in god even if there is no proof that one exists. There has not been a single verifiable case of an actual miraculous cure. Pascals wager and the many gods objection request pdf. Suppose there are many other god possibilities, perhaps even an infinite number of possible gods, and for each a pascals wager could formulated that recommends inculcating that particular belief. Blaise pascal 16231662 was a 17 th century french mathematician and scientist who, sadly, died at the age of 39 in a vehicle accident. Blaise pascal biography from the catholic encyclopedia. In pascals wager, jordan defends a version of pascals famous argument 1670 that it is rational to believe, or to try to induce belief, in god. Only nontheists go to heaven 2002 by richard carrier the empty wager by sam harris the rejection of pascals wager 2010 by paul tobin. It posits that humans bet with their lives that god either exists or does not.
Pascals wager is the name given to an argument due to blaise pascal for believing, or for at least taking steps to believe, in god. Pascals wager about god blaise pascal 16231662 offers a pragmatic reason for believing in god. Pascals wager 325 the case of religion, where traditions are at odds with each other, and where, moreover, explanations are available for the persistence of traditional beliefs that has nothing to do with their truth. Pascals wager, practical argument for belief in god formulated by blaise pascal. What is distinctive about pascals approach to the latter question is that he thinks that we can answer it without. Pascals wager is an argument for the existence of god developed by 17th century mathematician and philosopher blaise pascal. Pascals approach to the latter question is that he thinks that we can answer it without. Pascals wager ontario consultants on religious tolerance. In his pensees 165758, pascal posed the following argument to show that belief in the christian religion is rational.
It reasons thereupon,and calls it nature, necessity, and can believe nothing else. Pascals wager is an argument in philosophy presented by the seventeenthcentury french philosopher, mathematician and physicist, blaise pascal 16231662. Pascal s wager 325 the case of religion, where traditions are at odds with each other, and where, moreover, explanations are available for the persistence of traditional beliefs that has nothing to do with their truth. To understand pascals wager you have to understand the background of the argument. As terence penelhum has noted, many philosophers feel it is somehow a professional obligation not to accept it.
The dilemma that republican policy makers confronted regarding exchanges was, as an insurance department official in a conservative state told us, reminiscent of pascals wager. The name is somewhat misleading, for in a single section of his pensees, pascal apparently presents at least three such arguments, each of which might be called a wager it is only the final of these that is traditionally referred to as pascal. Armed with the results of critical historical research and. A skeptics guide to the rejection of christian beliefs. What major objections can you construct to the wager. Pascals wager has fascinated philosophers far in excess of its reputation as effective apologetics. Pascals wager superb analysis of the argument by alan hajek. A skeptic s guide to the rejection of christian beliefs. He is considered to be the father of modern probability theory. All of the traditions we had when i was a child that still to this day brings back joyous memories and warmth in my heart. Pascals wager is the most prominent theistic pragmatic argument, and issues in epistemology, the ethics of belief, and decision theory, as well as philosophical theology, all intersect at the wager. Facing uncertainty over whether god exists, seventeenthcentury french philosopher blaise pascal 1669 1995 concluded that the safest way to live is by assuming. In addition, pascals wager does not prove the existence of gd, but the logic in believing or striving to believe in him.
Pascal s wager is finding ever more defenders who aim to undermine the old many gods objection. Rota considers pascals wager and the roles of uncertainty, evidence and faith in making a commitment to god. Theistic belief and religious uncertainty by jeffrey jordan. Medieval philosophy was dead, and medieval theology was being ignored or sneered at by the new intellectuals of the scientific revolution of the seventeenth century. A rational person would act according to whichever set of different religious traditions that promise infinite consequences and do not conflict with each other, weighted by which set he thinks. Jun 28, 2008 in pascals wager, jordan defends a version of pascals famous argument 1670 that it is rational to believe, or to try to induce belief, in god. Two main objections are often raised to pascals wager. Second, even if tradition gives pascals hypoth esis far greater probability than gales, there would still be no reason for. A live hypothesis is a proposition whose adoption would not. Swinburne in the christian wager, religious studies iv 1969, 21728. Clarify the meaning of pascals sentence, the heart has its reasons which reason does not know. May 06, 2012 the flaws of pascals wager an argument often used by religious people is that they have nothing to lose by believing in god and that atheists are risking eternity in hell for no gain. An epistemic interpretation of the ultimate pragmatic argument mi c h a e l ve l c h i k p iquant, convincing, powerful, and mildly heretical pascals wager is a philosophers dream.
Pascals wager as an argument for not believing in god. The rejection of pascal s wager brief refutation of pascal by paul tobin. And this being so, if there were an infinity of chances, of which one only would be for you, you would still be right in wagering one to win two, and you would act stupidly, being obliged to play, by refusing to stake one life against. Author paul tobin shows the bible, with its numerous contradictions, historical errors and scientific inaccuracies, cannot be considered inerrant. Pascal, who is said to be the father of modern probability, felt that that religion should be approached as a gamble.
The rejection of pascals wager brief refutation of pascal by paul tobin. Armed with the results of critical historical research and a mind free from the shackles of dogma, paul tobin dissects the bible and the historical jesus in a way only a sceptic can. If this supposition should turn out true, then, at best, pascals wager would no longer provide unique support for theism. Subtracting the utility of not paying from that of paying we havep1 p21 p4w but since. Second, even if tradition gives pascal s hypoth esis far greater probability than gale s, there would still be no reason for. This is a plausible principle, and one which is employed in some versions of pascals wager. Pascals wager puts the choice and onus on the individual, whereas, the atheist wager places the onus on gd without a clear foundation. So far we have discussed a number of arguments for or against the. He guides us through the intricacies of modern archaeology and comparative. I propose to reformulate pascals wager as urging those who doubt gods existence to embrace a doubt of desire rather than a doubt of indifference. After describing the wager and the objection, i report on. Using either of the two wellknown rules of decision making under uncertainty the maximax or minimax ruleone should believe in god. The rejection of pascal s wager in the seventeenth century the french mathematician and theologian, blaise pascal 1623 1663 put forward a wager in his pensees thoughts.
We find collected in this book the bible the superstitious beliefs of the ancient inhabitants of palestine, with indistinct echoes of indian and persian fables, mistaken imitation of egyptian theories and customs, historical chronicles as dry as they are unreliable and miscellaneous poems, amatory, human and jewishnational, which is. Most discussions of the wager concentrate on what jordan calls the canonical version, according to which one should cultivate religious belief because of the possibility of an infinite reward which, even if it is discounted by allowing only a. Reconstruct pascals wager as carefully as possible. It posits that humans bet with their lives that god either exists or does not pascal argues that a rational person should live as though god exists and seek to believe in god. This means, first, that they should hope and therefore desire that they might find a higher meaning and value to their existence by making contact with a beneficent power beyond the. The facts of pascals life, so far as they are necessary for this brief introduction to the pensees, are as follows. Explain whether you consider pascals wager a proof of gods existence or not. Ian hacking 1972 pointed out that pascals text involves three different versions of the argument. Pascals wager is the most famous part of his collection of notes known as the pensees. As terence penelhum has noted, many philosophers feel it is. Sep 28, 2015 i propose to reformulate pascals wager as urging those who doubt gods existence to embrace a doubt of desire rather than a doubt of indifference. Pascals wager a good summary of the argument by paul saka.
Whether anyone would be convinced by such an argument seems not to be the main thrust of pascals formulation of the wager. According to pascal, how much can be known about god. Such selfseeking individuals would not properly serve the deity. A skeptics guide to the bible and the historical jesus that critically analysis the problems with the bible, starting with genesis through to revelation. If there is a god, he is infinitely incomprehensible, since, having, neither parts nor limits, he has no affinity to us. Thomas aquinas c12251274 is arguably the most important catholic theologian in history. By engaging with themes such as decision theory, the finetuning of the universe, divine hiddenness, the problem of evil, the historicity of the resurrection and the nature of miracles, he probes the many dynamics at work in embracing. A skeptic s guide to the bible and the historical jesus that critically analysis the problems with the bible, starting with genesis through to revelation. The manygods objection the most common criticism directed toward the wager is that pascal has set his betting partition too narrowly, that there are possibilities that pascal ignored and that drastically affect the wager. If the christian god does not exist, the agnostic loses little by believing in him and gains correspondingly little by not believing.
This is considered the most important quote in pascal s writing. The objection concedes that it makes sense to think of the. Many times i sit of when i was a youngster under the age of five when i lived in kaycee, wyoming. But since it was embedded in the pensees, which was pascals life project to defend christian thought, it seems unlikely he intended for the wager to stand alone. With the wager, pascal attempted to provide a compelling reason to believe in god based upon happiness and possible outcomes. The rejection of pascals wager in the seventeenth century the french mathematician and theologian, blaise pascal 1623 1663 put forward a wager in his pensees thoughts. Bandette, drawn by colleen coover, was awarded the eisner award for best digital series in 20, 2016, and 2017.
498 1565 1406 60 1567 453 627 820 1309 773 1371 1638 900 191 472 568 881 481 1285 114 1002 1573 911 1218 76 915 37 790 582 674 1415 682 643 1460 975